Tuesday, February 03, 2004
From: Abhik Gupta
Date: Sun Feb 1, 2004 10:57 pm
Subject: Veg vs. Non-veg
Dear all,
I have been following the interesting viewpoints on
veg and non-veg with a lot of interest. Veg diet may
be good for health, but it also depends on how you
cook it. If you deep fry your vegetables in oil, and
use excess of spices, I do not think it's going to be
good. Also, depends on your age and activity level. I
have doubts whether sportmen and women would be able
to do very well without consuming red meat. Again, if
you use oil sparingly, fish could be a safe and
excellent food (every Bengali will vouch for that, of
course).
So, the bottom line could be: moderation is beautiful-
whether veg or non-veg.
Best wishes
Abhik Gupta
Date: Sun Feb 1, 2004 10:57 pm
Subject: Veg vs. Non-veg
Dear all,
I have been following the interesting viewpoints on
veg and non-veg with a lot of interest. Veg diet may
be good for health, but it also depends on how you
cook it. If you deep fry your vegetables in oil, and
use excess of spices, I do not think it's going to be
good. Also, depends on your age and activity level. I
have doubts whether sportmen and women would be able
to do very well without consuming red meat. Again, if
you use oil sparingly, fish could be a safe and
excellent food (every Bengali will vouch for that, of
course).
So, the bottom line could be: moderation is beautiful-
whether veg or non-veg.
Best wishes
Abhik Gupta
From: "K.K.Verma"
Date: Fri Jan 30, 2004 5:56 pm
Subject: soul problem/easr-west mind problem.
Dear All,
In the recent issue of Aiba News Link (vol.7. no.1, Feb. 2004) Dr. J. Azariah has reviewed responses to the two points, raised by him, viz. (i) “I am a soul” and “I have a soul” – which is more correct?, and (ii) Are eastern and western minds different?.
I gave my responses to both these questions, but am sorry to find that my views have been wrongly reproduced in the review by Dr. Azariah.
On the soul problem I suggested an anlogy – the physical body is like a vehicle and the soul its driver. In the News Link review it has been said, “Verma thinks that (i) mind is the driver and the soul is the car…”. I gather that there was no ambiguity in my e-mail communication, as Dr Manoj in his e-mail letter to the Aiba group, dated 16-01-04, has cited me correctly. A question raised by Dr. Azariah in his review – “What about the petrol?”. An obvious answer to this question is, “For the vehicle or physical body the fuel is the food we take.”. Another question from him – “Does it mean the driver can change the car?”. In the Hindu philosophy is included the concept of rebirth, and according to this concept soul the driver changes the vehicle or the physical body. “It” may even change the model of the vehicle, as “it” may pass from one “yoni” (or level of organization) to another.
On the problem of east-west mind I said in my communication, “East and West minds are basically similar, being conspecific.”. In the review I have been quoted as saying, “East and west minds are basically similar, but conspecific.”. The two statements are widely different. A question raised by Dr Azariah in this context – “Will such external influences lead to “eugenic moulding”?”. I have clearly said in my note that of late the adjective “eugenic” has been liberally used for all measures for amelioration of man, whether genetic or not; see Smith (1973), cited in my note. Hence trying to search for genetic meaning in my phrase “eugenic moulding” is not needed.
Date: Fri Jan 30, 2004 5:56 pm
Subject: soul problem/easr-west mind problem.
Dear All,
In the recent issue of Aiba News Link (vol.7. no.1, Feb. 2004) Dr. J. Azariah has reviewed responses to the two points, raised by him, viz. (i) “I am a soul” and “I have a soul” – which is more correct?, and (ii) Are eastern and western minds different?.
I gave my responses to both these questions, but am sorry to find that my views have been wrongly reproduced in the review by Dr. Azariah.
On the soul problem I suggested an anlogy – the physical body is like a vehicle and the soul its driver. In the News Link review it has been said, “Verma thinks that (i) mind is the driver and the soul is the car…”. I gather that there was no ambiguity in my e-mail communication, as Dr Manoj in his e-mail letter to the Aiba group, dated 16-01-04, has cited me correctly. A question raised by Dr. Azariah in his review – “What about the petrol?”. An obvious answer to this question is, “For the vehicle or physical body the fuel is the food we take.”. Another question from him – “Does it mean the driver can change the car?”. In the Hindu philosophy is included the concept of rebirth, and according to this concept soul the driver changes the vehicle or the physical body. “It” may even change the model of the vehicle, as “it” may pass from one “yoni” (or level of organization) to another.
On the problem of east-west mind I said in my communication, “East and West minds are basically similar, being conspecific.”. In the review I have been quoted as saying, “East and west minds are basically similar, but conspecific.”. The two statements are widely different. A question raised by Dr Azariah in this context – “Will such external influences lead to “eugenic moulding”?”. I have clearly said in my note that of late the adjective “eugenic” has been liberally used for all measures for amelioration of man, whether genetic or not; see Smith (1973), cited in my note. Hence trying to search for genetic meaning in my phrase “eugenic moulding” is not needed.
From: "drdsheriff"
Date: Wed Jan 28, 2004 8:02 pm
Subject: Re: [aiba_bioethics_club] Re: Veg or Non veg
It is great to see that there is long debate about vegetarianism versus
non-vegetarianism. Plants were considered to be the source of nutrition for
humankind to nurture. To protect this plant from human exploitation for
eating alone- cellulose was protected from being eaten as humans donot have
the enzyme to do so. Man being a natural hunter- meat became a source of
food so that plants could be spared from being totally used as a source of
energy. It is not the question what we eat is meat or plant. It is how we
respect life for both plants and animals are living beings. They have souls
and they have their rights to be in the globe. We cannot quote scriptures
or sayings of sages to give an explanation why we are vegetarians or not.
Vegetarianism came into focus scientists thought that it is a safe food to
depend upon as man was subjected to coronary artery disease, other clinical
conditions associated with eating saturated food stuff. People eat
processed food- like fried rice which are rich only in monounsaturated
fatty acids pushing a quite sizeable population of youngsters into the
pathology of heart attacks. It is a necessit felt now very badly for people
have taken to the habit of eating pocketed, processed food which appeal to
the palate at the cost of one's health. It has resutled in the concept
replacement - instead of one apple a day with one aspirin a day keeps the
doctor away. Lastly these value based food choices are there for us who
have the option of getting atleast one meal a day. It is not there for
quite a sizeable population who have no choice but to eat on whatever their
hands lay on. If wishes were horses beggars will ride them so said Ruskin.
Poor people donot have that luxury of making such a choice. Therefore meat
becomes the poor man's nutrition for it is available at a cheapter rate.
Let us not forget the words of Gandhiji-food, clothes and shelter the three
basic necessities of life- for many it is still a distant dream. You could
see even now- man fighting with the animal to eat what is thrown into the
dustbin of many cities. Let us pray that we will respect food whatever the
source it comes from. That respect alone will help protect our environment.
sheriff
Date: Wed Jan 28, 2004 8:02 pm
Subject: Re: [aiba_bioethics_club] Re: Veg or Non veg
It is great to see that there is long debate about vegetarianism versus
non-vegetarianism. Plants were considered to be the source of nutrition for
humankind to nurture. To protect this plant from human exploitation for
eating alone- cellulose was protected from being eaten as humans donot have
the enzyme to do so. Man being a natural hunter- meat became a source of
food so that plants could be spared from being totally used as a source of
energy. It is not the question what we eat is meat or plant. It is how we
respect life for both plants and animals are living beings. They have souls
and they have their rights to be in the globe. We cannot quote scriptures
or sayings of sages to give an explanation why we are vegetarians or not.
Vegetarianism came into focus scientists thought that it is a safe food to
depend upon as man was subjected to coronary artery disease, other clinical
conditions associated with eating saturated food stuff. People eat
processed food- like fried rice which are rich only in monounsaturated
fatty acids pushing a quite sizeable population of youngsters into the
pathology of heart attacks. It is a necessit felt now very badly for people
have taken to the habit of eating pocketed, processed food which appeal to
the palate at the cost of one's health. It has resutled in the concept
replacement - instead of one apple a day with one aspirin a day keeps the
doctor away. Lastly these value based food choices are there for us who
have the option of getting atleast one meal a day. It is not there for
quite a sizeable population who have no choice but to eat on whatever their
hands lay on. If wishes were horses beggars will ride them so said Ruskin.
Poor people donot have that luxury of making such a choice. Therefore meat
becomes the poor man's nutrition for it is available at a cheapter rate.
Let us not forget the words of Gandhiji-food, clothes and shelter the three
basic necessities of life- for many it is still a distant dream. You could
see even now- man fighting with the animal to eat what is thrown into the
dustbin of many cities. Let us pray that we will respect food whatever the
source it comes from. That respect alone will help protect our environment.
sheriff
From: "goodindk"
Date: Wed Jan 28, 2004 5:22 am
Subject: Bioethics & Vegetarianism
Without question, meat is indeed a central aspect of spirituality
within many religious traditions. As the Islamic Ramzan festival and
the Hindu feast for Kali were already mentioned, I will share about
the role of meat in Judeo-Christianity. The Hebrew Bible reveals
that all of humankind was required by God to be vegetarian, for all
the generations from Adam to Noah. Only after the great flood did
God allow humankind to begin eating meat. But as a condition of the
covenant, humankind was made responsible for the care and protection
of the animal species. Eating meat is therefore a reminder of the
righteousness of Noah, that his virtue saved the human species from
destruction in the flood. Eating meat is also a reminder of the
covenant the humans made with the animals and God.
A great theological question is to ask what were the sins that
provoked God's wrath, and produced the flood. As the only law in
that time in biblical history was the prohibition against eating
meat, some have concluded that it was in fact the killing and eating
of animals which angered God. The Christian theologian Tertullian
and the Rabbis who wrote the Bereshit Rabbah held this view. Another
theological question is to ask whether the permission to eat meat was
a "reward" to Noah, or a harder test of humankind's virtue.
Tertullian concluded that meat was not a reward, but a dangerous
invitation toward greater hedonism, gluttony, and sin – that even
though meat was permitted, humankind's regard for animals was still
one test used by God to determine our virtue.
So, there is no question that meat plays a powerful spiritual role in
religious life. Some may partake in meat with great reverence for
God. Other religious seekers may abstain from meat or fast from all
food for a period of time for the same reason. While these behaviors
may seem contradictory, they both seek to honor God. I am reminded
of the words of the Apostle Paul in Romans 14:3, "let no him who eats
despise him who does not eat, and let him who does not eat judge him
who eats; for God has received him." While Paul was speaking about
those who observed Judaic dietary laws in a mixed community of
gentiles and Christianized-Jews, the message holds for vegetarian
versus carnivores. So, in my opinion, it is not meat itself which is
wrong, but how the animals are treated and regarded by society that
makes it a sin within Judeo-Christianity. I would argue that meat
should be optional, rarely ingested, and revered for the sentient
life it once contained. But in the global economy, meat is a mere
commodity to be mass produced to the detriment of the planet's
ecosystems, inhumane to the animals, and is also socially /
bioethically wrong for it deprives impoverished nations access to
nutritive grains which are instead used to feed cattle for the richer
nations.
Yes, plants have feelings, and respond to environmental stress with
unmistakable signals of trauma. In early Christianity, plants were
also considered to have souls, along with animals and humans. St.
Maximos the Confessor (580-662 CE) reflected on the platonic powers
of the soul in his work entitled "Four Hundred Texts on Love"
(Philokalia 2:88):
The soul has three powers: first, the power of nourishment and
growth; second, that of imagination and instinct; third, that of
intelligence and intellect. Plants share only in the first of these
powers; animals share in the first and second; men share in all
three. The first two powers are perishable; the third is clearly
imperishable and immortal.
But while plants had simple souls, animals were seen to have souls
2/3 the same as ours. This further empowerment of the animals is
also reflected in that animals can "suffer" as people can, while
plants can only sense environmental stress – but not pain. The
animals experience the world much like people do. They feel joy and
pain, desire to procreate and nurture their young, and suffer for the
loss of their offspring. Because of this, philosophers such as Peter
Singer and Albert Schweitzer conclude that the killing of a sentient
being, whether animal or human, is always wrong because it inflicts
unnecessary suffering, and thus reflects badly upon morality of
person. The killing of animals is therefore perilously close the
killing of human beings. This is why in Judaism, the slaughter of
animals was controlled by the priests, and performed as painlessly as
possible to the animal – any animal that suffered while being killed
could not be eaten (kosher laws).
I am reminded of a Hare Krishna temple that advertised its vegetarian
food as "karma free." This makes a lot of sense. The literal
meaning of the word nutrition is to nurture oneself. It would not be
possible to "nurture" oneself through the suffering of animals,
ingesting that karma with the slaughtered meat. Plants, however, do
not suffer. They are therefore free of bad karma for the one eating
the plant.
Moreover, in many cases, the plant wants to be eaten. This is most
clear with trees that produce fruit. The tree knows (to
anthropomorphize the tree for the moment) that if its fruit is eaten,
the seeds inside the fruit will be scattered to new areas for new
trees to grow. This is how trees reproduce, for if the fruit fell
and rotted beneath the parent tree, the seeds would have too much
shade to grow. So, the tree grows its fruit to be appealing to
people and animals, in hopes the fruit will be taken, and the seeds
dispersed to new area. This is part of nature's plan.
With respect to the talking points offered by Dr. Azariah, and
trophic levels of ecology, the 10% rule should be remembered with
respect to the fairness of meat to impoverished people. 10-times as
much grain can be harvested for human consumption than using that
grain to feed to cattle for meat. This is partly why meat is so much
more expensive, and why (as Manoj mentioned) some richer nations have
the poorer nations raise cattle for export – cattle the local people
can't afford. Worse, the locals have to suffer the problems of soil
erosion from over-grazing, and drinking water pollution from the
ranch runoff. I would also guess that the money from the cattle
ranches is mostly kept by the landowners, and not shared with the
people who inherit the pollution. That land could be better used to
raise nutritious grain for the locals to eat, or export to
impoverished nations who can afford grain, but not the meat.
It is also interesting to note that too much meat causes nutrition
deficiency. This was discovered by the colonial British. They would
set sail with only meat provisions, which were "cured" so as to not
spoil. On long journeys, the crew would start to develop diseases
like scurvy. The cure was to eat fresh fruit, such as limes. This
is why an old slang term for the British was "limeys," as British
sailors were always searching for limes in the ports they'd visit.
Genetically modified food is troublesome. In the USA, half the
grains harvested are used to feed cattle, which are now chained
together in feedlots for their entire lives (suffering). Overseas,
pristine lands are cleared for livestock operations, which in turn
threatens endangered species who need that land for their ranges and
habitats. All this is done to produce mass quantities of meat for
consumers, here and around the world. I suspect if meat consumption
was reduced, there would not be a need for GM grains, as there would
be plenty of grain for everyone.
While vegetarianism will not solve all the world's ecological and
social problems, this is one of the few problems each person can take
action on. Most global problems involve governments and
international economies, and one person has a difficult time making a
difference against such megaliths of indifference. But becoming a
vegetarian makes a real difference (especially to the animals), and
in time, with enough people who act the same way, even governments
and international economies will take notice. Something to think
about while you are deciding what to have for dinner !
So, I would argue that meat, in-of-itself, is not a sin. But too
much meat has serious bioethical consequences. Reducing meat
consumption to just the rare luxury, or for religious feasts, should
be a bioethical aspiration, and one means to reduce global hunger,
reduce water pollution (bio-waste runoff), control soil erosion (over-
grazing), and help preserve endangered species (stop clearing lands
for cattle ranches).
DKG
Date: Wed Jan 28, 2004 5:22 am
Subject: Bioethics & Vegetarianism
Without question, meat is indeed a central aspect of spirituality
within many religious traditions. As the Islamic Ramzan festival and
the Hindu feast for Kali were already mentioned, I will share about
the role of meat in Judeo-Christianity. The Hebrew Bible reveals
that all of humankind was required by God to be vegetarian, for all
the generations from Adam to Noah. Only after the great flood did
God allow humankind to begin eating meat. But as a condition of the
covenant, humankind was made responsible for the care and protection
of the animal species. Eating meat is therefore a reminder of the
righteousness of Noah, that his virtue saved the human species from
destruction in the flood. Eating meat is also a reminder of the
covenant the humans made with the animals and God.
A great theological question is to ask what were the sins that
provoked God's wrath, and produced the flood. As the only law in
that time in biblical history was the prohibition against eating
meat, some have concluded that it was in fact the killing and eating
of animals which angered God. The Christian theologian Tertullian
and the Rabbis who wrote the Bereshit Rabbah held this view. Another
theological question is to ask whether the permission to eat meat was
a "reward" to Noah, or a harder test of humankind's virtue.
Tertullian concluded that meat was not a reward, but a dangerous
invitation toward greater hedonism, gluttony, and sin – that even
though meat was permitted, humankind's regard for animals was still
one test used by God to determine our virtue.
So, there is no question that meat plays a powerful spiritual role in
religious life. Some may partake in meat with great reverence for
God. Other religious seekers may abstain from meat or fast from all
food for a period of time for the same reason. While these behaviors
may seem contradictory, they both seek to honor God. I am reminded
of the words of the Apostle Paul in Romans 14:3, "let no him who eats
despise him who does not eat, and let him who does not eat judge him
who eats; for God has received him." While Paul was speaking about
those who observed Judaic dietary laws in a mixed community of
gentiles and Christianized-Jews, the message holds for vegetarian
versus carnivores. So, in my opinion, it is not meat itself which is
wrong, but how the animals are treated and regarded by society that
makes it a sin within Judeo-Christianity. I would argue that meat
should be optional, rarely ingested, and revered for the sentient
life it once contained. But in the global economy, meat is a mere
commodity to be mass produced to the detriment of the planet's
ecosystems, inhumane to the animals, and is also socially /
bioethically wrong for it deprives impoverished nations access to
nutritive grains which are instead used to feed cattle for the richer
nations.
Yes, plants have feelings, and respond to environmental stress with
unmistakable signals of trauma. In early Christianity, plants were
also considered to have souls, along with animals and humans. St.
Maximos the Confessor (580-662 CE) reflected on the platonic powers
of the soul in his work entitled "Four Hundred Texts on Love"
(Philokalia 2:88):
The soul has three powers: first, the power of nourishment and
growth; second, that of imagination and instinct; third, that of
intelligence and intellect. Plants share only in the first of these
powers; animals share in the first and second; men share in all
three. The first two powers are perishable; the third is clearly
imperishable and immortal.
But while plants had simple souls, animals were seen to have souls
2/3 the same as ours. This further empowerment of the animals is
also reflected in that animals can "suffer" as people can, while
plants can only sense environmental stress – but not pain. The
animals experience the world much like people do. They feel joy and
pain, desire to procreate and nurture their young, and suffer for the
loss of their offspring. Because of this, philosophers such as Peter
Singer and Albert Schweitzer conclude that the killing of a sentient
being, whether animal or human, is always wrong because it inflicts
unnecessary suffering, and thus reflects badly upon morality of
person. The killing of animals is therefore perilously close the
killing of human beings. This is why in Judaism, the slaughter of
animals was controlled by the priests, and performed as painlessly as
possible to the animal – any animal that suffered while being killed
could not be eaten (kosher laws).
I am reminded of a Hare Krishna temple that advertised its vegetarian
food as "karma free." This makes a lot of sense. The literal
meaning of the word nutrition is to nurture oneself. It would not be
possible to "nurture" oneself through the suffering of animals,
ingesting that karma with the slaughtered meat. Plants, however, do
not suffer. They are therefore free of bad karma for the one eating
the plant.
Moreover, in many cases, the plant wants to be eaten. This is most
clear with trees that produce fruit. The tree knows (to
anthropomorphize the tree for the moment) that if its fruit is eaten,
the seeds inside the fruit will be scattered to new areas for new
trees to grow. This is how trees reproduce, for if the fruit fell
and rotted beneath the parent tree, the seeds would have too much
shade to grow. So, the tree grows its fruit to be appealing to
people and animals, in hopes the fruit will be taken, and the seeds
dispersed to new area. This is part of nature's plan.
With respect to the talking points offered by Dr. Azariah, and
trophic levels of ecology, the 10% rule should be remembered with
respect to the fairness of meat to impoverished people. 10-times as
much grain can be harvested for human consumption than using that
grain to feed to cattle for meat. This is partly why meat is so much
more expensive, and why (as Manoj mentioned) some richer nations have
the poorer nations raise cattle for export – cattle the local people
can't afford. Worse, the locals have to suffer the problems of soil
erosion from over-grazing, and drinking water pollution from the
ranch runoff. I would also guess that the money from the cattle
ranches is mostly kept by the landowners, and not shared with the
people who inherit the pollution. That land could be better used to
raise nutritious grain for the locals to eat, or export to
impoverished nations who can afford grain, but not the meat.
It is also interesting to note that too much meat causes nutrition
deficiency. This was discovered by the colonial British. They would
set sail with only meat provisions, which were "cured" so as to not
spoil. On long journeys, the crew would start to develop diseases
like scurvy. The cure was to eat fresh fruit, such as limes. This
is why an old slang term for the British was "limeys," as British
sailors were always searching for limes in the ports they'd visit.
Genetically modified food is troublesome. In the USA, half the
grains harvested are used to feed cattle, which are now chained
together in feedlots for their entire lives (suffering). Overseas,
pristine lands are cleared for livestock operations, which in turn
threatens endangered species who need that land for their ranges and
habitats. All this is done to produce mass quantities of meat for
consumers, here and around the world. I suspect if meat consumption
was reduced, there would not be a need for GM grains, as there would
be plenty of grain for everyone.
While vegetarianism will not solve all the world's ecological and
social problems, this is one of the few problems each person can take
action on. Most global problems involve governments and
international economies, and one person has a difficult time making a
difference against such megaliths of indifference. But becoming a
vegetarian makes a real difference (especially to the animals), and
in time, with enough people who act the same way, even governments
and international economies will take notice. Something to think
about while you are deciding what to have for dinner !
So, I would argue that meat, in-of-itself, is not a sin. But too
much meat has serious bioethical consequences. Reducing meat
consumption to just the rare luxury, or for religious feasts, should
be a bioethical aspiration, and one means to reduce global hunger,
reduce water pollution (bio-waste runoff), control soil erosion (over-
grazing), and help preserve endangered species (stop clearing lands
for cattle ranches).
DKG
From: Jayapal Azariah
Date: Sun Jan 25, 2004 7:03 pm
Subject: Re: [aiba_bioethics_club] Re: Veg or Non veg
This topic can be discussed under the following three
heads.
1. Ecological view point. How energy is uplifted in
the trophic chain and the ecological efficiency.
2. Nutritive value of plants e.g. the source of iodine
3. Food security in plants and growing population and
demand
Jay
Date: Sun Jan 25, 2004 7:03 pm
Subject: Re: [aiba_bioethics_club] Re: Veg or Non veg
This topic can be discussed under the following three
heads.
1. Ecological view point. How energy is uplifted in
the trophic chain and the ecological efficiency.
2. Nutritive value of plants e.g. the source of iodine
3. Food security in plants and growing population and
demand
Jay
From: "V.R.Manoj"
Date: Sun Jan 25, 2004 4:01 pm
Subject: response to Mr.David's comment on vegetarianism
Dear David,
How are you ?
Okay, while I have to agree with you on the obvious health benefits of
vegetarianism, I would like to share a few pointers and look for
Dr.Sheriff's covering fire in this regard. When I was doing my post
graduation, my classmate was a devout muslim from Bangladesh. I had the
oppurtunity to take part in the ramzan feast [ the feast which comes after
the fasting period ]. What I observed was the spiritual importance they
placed to eating meat. A vegetarian menu was simply out of the question. It
was a difficult concept for me to accept because I am a hindu and although a
non vegetarian one, we do not place such an enormous religious importance on
consuming meat.
However, I would like to point out several hindu festivals where the eating
of meat is assosiated. This is especially true with regard to goddess Kali
[ the goddess of war, death and destruction ].
I guess people have traditionally offered what they considered as their most
prized possession as an offering to God. In that respect, meat offerings and
cultures surrounding meat eating are not unethical from a human centric
point of view.
My most favourite argument against vegatarians is that plants have feelings
too. Dr.Jagdish chandra bose had demonstrated the chemosensory and
photosensory perceptions of pain in plants. So, you are actually not being
less cruel by eating a tomato. As a microbiologist, I have actually seen the
cell damage to the plant when you pluck a tomato.
However, I do disagree with the huge industry that has come up as a result
of the meat eating culture. It is a well known fact that third world
countries dedicate several hundred acres of useful land to cultivate
feedstock for livestock in developed countries. This is a problem.
Bioethically, these are the issues that require focus rather than addressing
the individual pallette. Also, I do not think the vegetarians should be let
off the hook so easily. Just look at the amazing concentrations of residual
pesticides in all of our bodies [ no matter how much we deny it, we all have
a small trace of DDT in our cells ]. Also, there are now a wide variety of
GM crops which raise questions of food security. Poor farmers cannot
cultivate the new GM crops because of all the complicated patent issues.
Therefore, I rest my case by saying that whether vegetarian or not, you have
a bioethical problem. I don't think it can simply dissappear by changing a
non-vegetarian diet to a vegetarian diet.
Thanks,
V.R.Manoj. AIBA.
[ www.vrmanoj.com ]
Date: Sun Jan 25, 2004 4:01 pm
Subject: response to Mr.David's comment on vegetarianism
Dear David,
How are you ?
Okay, while I have to agree with you on the obvious health benefits of
vegetarianism, I would like to share a few pointers and look for
Dr.Sheriff's covering fire in this regard. When I was doing my post
graduation, my classmate was a devout muslim from Bangladesh. I had the
oppurtunity to take part in the ramzan feast [ the feast which comes after
the fasting period ]. What I observed was the spiritual importance they
placed to eating meat. A vegetarian menu was simply out of the question. It
was a difficult concept for me to accept because I am a hindu and although a
non vegetarian one, we do not place such an enormous religious importance on
consuming meat.
However, I would like to point out several hindu festivals where the eating
of meat is assosiated. This is especially true with regard to goddess Kali
[ the goddess of war, death and destruction ].
I guess people have traditionally offered what they considered as their most
prized possession as an offering to God. In that respect, meat offerings and
cultures surrounding meat eating are not unethical from a human centric
point of view.
My most favourite argument against vegatarians is that plants have feelings
too. Dr.Jagdish chandra bose had demonstrated the chemosensory and
photosensory perceptions of pain in plants. So, you are actually not being
less cruel by eating a tomato. As a microbiologist, I have actually seen the
cell damage to the plant when you pluck a tomato.
However, I do disagree with the huge industry that has come up as a result
of the meat eating culture. It is a well known fact that third world
countries dedicate several hundred acres of useful land to cultivate
feedstock for livestock in developed countries. This is a problem.
Bioethically, these are the issues that require focus rather than addressing
the individual pallette. Also, I do not think the vegetarians should be let
off the hook so easily. Just look at the amazing concentrations of residual
pesticides in all of our bodies [ no matter how much we deny it, we all have
a small trace of DDT in our cells ]. Also, there are now a wide variety of
GM crops which raise questions of food security. Poor farmers cannot
cultivate the new GM crops because of all the complicated patent issues.
Therefore, I rest my case by saying that whether vegetarian or not, you have
a bioethical problem. I don't think it can simply dissappear by changing a
non-vegetarian diet to a vegetarian diet.
Thanks,
V.R.Manoj. AIBA.
[ www.vrmanoj.com ]
From: "goodindk"
Date: Sat Jan 24, 2004 9:59 am
Subject: Re: Veg or Non veg
This is indeed a great topic for bioethics.
> Is veg diet hyped up?
> Does our physiology restrict us from Non veg diet.
The first evolutionary adaptation that allowed the human species to
progress from a (most humble) 100-lbs homind, to the de facto ruler
of this planet was the pastorial lifestyle.
Humans can't eat grass. But herbivores such as cattle can. The first
humans soon learned that it would be a really good idea to gather
herds of cattle together, and protect them from predators such as
lions. This worked to the advantage of the cattle as well, as they
no longer had to worry about being eaten. In exchange, the humans
would live off of the milk and sometimes blood of the cattle for
their nutritional needs. This was their defense against drought and
famine: the larger the herd of cattle, the better the chance of
surviving the drought. This is why the cattle were rarely eaten, as
they were more valued for there ability to turn grass into milk. So,
from the beginning, humans were mostly vegetarians.
The next adaptation was the agrarian lifestyle, where humans raised
crops of highly nutrious grains for harvest. Cattle were also very
vaulable, as they could be employed for field work - plowing the
fields, etc. Again, humans were mostly vegetarian as the wheat could
be harvested and processed to produced food as nutritous as meat. The
cattle was considered manual labor. But again, the cattle didn't
have to worry about lions or other predators. It was a symbiotic
relationship.
Even in hunter / gatherer societies existing today, 90% of the
nutrition is in the form of vegetarian sources. The hunting aspect
of these societies seems to serve ritualistic / male bonding /
warrior training needs, rather than nutritional requirements of the
tribe.
Only in a modern post-agrarian society do we find abundant meat as a
staple of western diets. The reverence of the cow as the "mother of
all food" has all but disappeared from the western mindset. It is no
longer a symbiotic relationship. Many have likened modern cattle
raising operations to slavery, not symbiosis.
The health benefits of vegetariansim is substantial. Chloresterol, a
principal causal factor is heart disease, is only found in animal
products. The risk of contamination "bio-accumulating" is a concern
with meat. This risk increases as you work up the food chain. This
is why mercury poisoning is a concern with eating fish, and not
vegetarian tofu. Usually, the closer you are to the plants, the lower
the risk you have for toxins.
With respect to bio-ethics, the vegetarian life choice seems more in-
line with Daryl Macer's motto that bio-ethics is "love of life," that
is all life. Humans certainly do not NEED meat to live. Meat is a
choice, a luxury of abundance. While to eat meat may not be a sin in
the Judeo-Christian sense of the word, meat is a choice that reveals
the character of the one choosing. If meat is regarded as coming
from the mother of all food, the cow, then the choice is made in
humility and reverence for the life that produced it. If meat is a
mere thing, a commodity to be purchased and consumed arbitrarily,
then it shows (I think) a deep disrespect for bioethics, and the
mutual Creator of both the cow and person.
Well, that is one vegetarians point of view on this subject.
DG
Date: Sat Jan 24, 2004 9:59 am
Subject: Re: Veg or Non veg
This is indeed a great topic for bioethics.
> Is veg diet hyped up?
> Does our physiology restrict us from Non veg diet.
The first evolutionary adaptation that allowed the human species to
progress from a (most humble) 100-lbs homind, to the de facto ruler
of this planet was the pastorial lifestyle.
Humans can't eat grass. But herbivores such as cattle can. The first
humans soon learned that it would be a really good idea to gather
herds of cattle together, and protect them from predators such as
lions. This worked to the advantage of the cattle as well, as they
no longer had to worry about being eaten. In exchange, the humans
would live off of the milk and sometimes blood of the cattle for
their nutritional needs. This was their defense against drought and
famine: the larger the herd of cattle, the better the chance of
surviving the drought. This is why the cattle were rarely eaten, as
they were more valued for there ability to turn grass into milk. So,
from the beginning, humans were mostly vegetarians.
The next adaptation was the agrarian lifestyle, where humans raised
crops of highly nutrious grains for harvest. Cattle were also very
vaulable, as they could be employed for field work - plowing the
fields, etc. Again, humans were mostly vegetarian as the wheat could
be harvested and processed to produced food as nutritous as meat. The
cattle was considered manual labor. But again, the cattle didn't
have to worry about lions or other predators. It was a symbiotic
relationship.
Even in hunter / gatherer societies existing today, 90% of the
nutrition is in the form of vegetarian sources. The hunting aspect
of these societies seems to serve ritualistic / male bonding /
warrior training needs, rather than nutritional requirements of the
tribe.
Only in a modern post-agrarian society do we find abundant meat as a
staple of western diets. The reverence of the cow as the "mother of
all food" has all but disappeared from the western mindset. It is no
longer a symbiotic relationship. Many have likened modern cattle
raising operations to slavery, not symbiosis.
The health benefits of vegetariansim is substantial. Chloresterol, a
principal causal factor is heart disease, is only found in animal
products. The risk of contamination "bio-accumulating" is a concern
with meat. This risk increases as you work up the food chain. This
is why mercury poisoning is a concern with eating fish, and not
vegetarian tofu. Usually, the closer you are to the plants, the lower
the risk you have for toxins.
With respect to bio-ethics, the vegetarian life choice seems more in-
line with Daryl Macer's motto that bio-ethics is "love of life," that
is all life. Humans certainly do not NEED meat to live. Meat is a
choice, a luxury of abundance. While to eat meat may not be a sin in
the Judeo-Christian sense of the word, meat is a choice that reveals
the character of the one choosing. If meat is regarded as coming
from the mother of all food, the cow, then the choice is made in
humility and reverence for the life that produced it. If meat is a
mere thing, a commodity to be purchased and consumed arbitrarily,
then it shows (I think) a deep disrespect for bioethics, and the
mutual Creator of both the cow and person.
Well, that is one vegetarians point of view on this subject.
DG
From: "vaz "
Date: Fri Jan 23, 2004 7:08 pm
Subject: Veg or Non veg
Dear all
At the outset I wish you good day. Recently we had a mindboggling controversial GD, "veg diet is good for health - a myth".
I would like to know he following.
Is veg diet hyped up?
Does our physiology restrict us from Non veg diet.
with regards
vaz
Date: Fri Jan 23, 2004 7:08 pm
Subject: Veg or Non veg
Dear all
At the outset I wish you good day. Recently we had a mindboggling controversial GD, "veg diet is good for health - a myth".
I would like to know he following.
Is veg diet hyped up?
Does our physiology restrict us from Non veg diet.
with regards
vaz
Sunday, February 01, 2004
This is the continuation of AIBA discussion logs. For the first installment , please see :http://www.vrmanoj.com/aiba/aibalog.html